"Gilbert creates the beauty and obsession of Clara’s music world … The great pleasure of this book is that the complexity is not resolved. There are surprises all along the way. It is different for each individual."
     —Booklist

"The tension builds to the competition, ending with Clara’s decision and small, unexpected gestures from the people she loves. A compassionate work."
     —Kirkus Reviews

"The strength of the novel lies … in the heroine’s in-depth exploration of what she truly wants for herself."
     —Publishers Weekly

"Suspenseful. And romantic …"
     —Horn Book

"Characterization is strong, with even the relatively minor characters … solidly realized. Descriptions of artistic expression are difficult at best, but Gilbert communicates the joy and style of the piano playing."
     —Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books

"Any teen trying to understand his or her path in life will understand Clara’s struggle. Booksell this one to all your students, not just the ones still practicing scales; it hits all the right notes beautifully —a definite winner."
     —Voice of Youth Advocate

"This complex, beautifully crafted novel has excellent characterization. While the novel may hold greater appeal for the artistically inclined, Clara’s struggle for her identity has universal power."
     —Children's Book Review Service, Inc.